The NTRO was set up in the summer of 2003. A year earlier, a Group of Ministers had handpicked RAW special secretary R.S. Bedi to set up the new intelligence outfit. The organisation was formally notified in July 2003.

In 2011 the comptroller and auditor general has unearthed a Rs 450-crore scam involving the purchase of Israeli unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) by the Hyderabad-based National Technical Research Organisation, a technical arm of the external intelligence agency Research and Analysis Wing.

The then national security adviser NSA M K Narayanan, who is now the West Bengal governor, had tried to scuttle the inquiry the CAG wanted to carry out in December 2009 The CAG, however, felt the tip-off was too serious to be ignored and hence approached the prime minister who overruled Narayanan’s objections and allowed the CAG sleuths to get cracking in January last year. NTRO chairman KVSS Prasada Rao, a scientist who retired last October, and its current adviser M S Vijayaraghavan, have been indicted in the CAG report. Source CAG nails RAW’s wing in Rs 450-cr UAV purchase scam

kvss-prasada-rao_021811102629M S Vijayraghavan

KVSS Prasada Rao and M S Vijayraghavan

In May 2008, Mittal, as head of NTRO’s Centre for Communications Applications (CCA) wrote to the then NTRO chairman K V S S Prasad Rao claiming that the use of satellite communication (SATCOM) equipment on board unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) was “never a part of the original request for proposal (RFP) or tender” and “hence no technical evaluation was carried out” at any stage by his division.

Although the SATCOM equipment were to be procured from two Israeli companies, Israeli Aerospace Industry (IAI) and ELTA, visits by CCA officers to these firms in Israel yielded little. “In all meetings (at least four times in Tel Aviv) CCA has been requesting IAA/ELTA to give details of the antenna and other systems associated with SATCOM onboard the UAV. Despite our concerted efforts and repeated demands, IAI/ELTA have REFUSED TO PART  with necessary information ,” documents in possession of Deccan Herald say.

Alarmingly, the trials of the SATCOM for UAVs, instead of being carried out in India were undertaken in Australia despite strong objections on the ground that the tests should be carried out in Indian conditions. The main reason why trials (which were to be witnessed by representatives of the Army, Air Force and the Navy) in Australia were not considered feasible was the IAI/ELTA had provided INCOMPLETE INFORMATION about the antenna proposed for SATCOM onboard UAVs. Besides, it was found that the antenna was “suboptimal” and “did not meet the requisite standard of radiation”, and that power amplifiers required modifications “to be able to meet digital modulation requirements.”

It was after  Mittal was served a memo, by the then NTRO adviser (in the rank of additional secretary) M S Vijayaraghavan for objecting to the SATCOM equipment deal that he quit the NTRO and blew the whistle on the goings-on in the country’s communications intelligence organisation.

Subsequent internal inquiries and special audits by the CAG in January 2010 (the NTRO was outside the purview of any government audit when it was formed) led to the chargesheeting of seven officers. Source Deccan Herald

Most media treated all this as a case of bribery to win a contract which it certainly was But there could be more to the whole story

Israel as a nation has a history of selling spy equipment which has backdoor traps to allow Israel to collect sensitive data

Israeli firm Nice System contains an undocumented account that provides administrator-level access to the product

Israeli firms Verint and Amdocs had ENCRYPTED TRAPDOORS  in Verint/Amdocs technology which allowed gathering data on Americans for transfer to Israeli intelligence

Israel was also indirectly involved in the notorious AT&T spy room 641A incident See Wikipedia  The NSA supposedly used a Narus STA600 for datamining/spying Naurus is a US based company started by two mysterious Israelis Ori Cohen and Stas Khirman

Coming back to NTRO the refusal  of the Israelis to provide information on the antennae used to communicate with SATCOMs (Satellite Communication) should have been a deal breaker in a spy equipment deal It did not because some officials were probably bribed

UAVs and Satcom equipment aren’t the only Israeli materials bought from Israel by NTRO

Every day, at a secret facility of the National Technical Research Organisation (NTRO) near Kala Ghoda in south Mumbai, a team of 18 operators sits peering through massive amounts of data coming in through undersea cables from across continents into an international gateway facility several kilometers away in Malad. The cables carry voice and internet data from Europe to Asia and vice versa

Mumbai (Kala Ghoda) eves dropping  facilities are now available in Delhi Calcutta Bangalore and at N K Narayan’s insistence in Hyderabad and Lucknow “We chose to duplicate them in Hyderabad and Lucknow, which have a large Muslim population; Bangalore, since it has a large foreign presence; Delhi and Calcutta since these are the other major cities. The Lucknow and Hyderabad facilities came up on M.K. Narayanan’s suggestion,” a senior intelligence official told Outlook.

The most intrusive of these systems are the off-the-air GSM/CDMA monitoring devices procured by various central and state intelligence organizations across the country. Sources estimate 90 such systems to have been bought so far , enabling intelligence agents to track, hear and record cellphone conversations at will without even approaching the telecom companies.

Verint Altitude1234

The surveillance raj has prompted several companies specialising in monitoring and data mining to enter the Indian market. “Israeli, Ukrainian and Russian companies offer the best systems . WE HAVE PURCHASED SEVERAL SYSTEMS FROM ISRAELI COMPANIES COMVERSE AND VERINT,” says an intelligence official. A Bangalore-based firm has also played a major role along with PSU Bharat Electronics Ltd in developing these systems,” says a source. But since NTRO is not authorised to do this monitoring, it works under the cover of the Intelligence Bureau. Source Outlook A Fox on a Fishing Expedition

Its not clear how many Israeli systems are in operation in India or which agency uses them for what purpose

Here are some links detailing the manner Israel spies on other nations (mainly US ) using  backdoor technology  in Comverse and Verint software 

How Israeli Backdoor Technology Penetrated the US Government’s Telecom System and Compromised National Security

Trojan Horse

Israeli Spying in the United States

Israeli Data Spies Have Eyes Focused on U.S. Citizens


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.


  1. rehmat1 says:

    On May 22, 2015, Zachary Keck, managing editor, The National Interest, an Israeli advocacy news outlet, posted an article, entitled, Watch Out, Pakistan: Israel to sell India Mobile Missiles.

    Keck says that Israeli defense minister Moshe Ya’alon while on visit to India in February, offered to sell “Israel’s prized Iron Dome short-range missile defense system.” The Iron Dome, also known as Iron Dumb failed miserably to detect and destroy Hamas’ mostly unguided rockets during the last Israel-Gaza war. The Israeli “prized Dome” cost $700 million to the US taxpayers.

    “India and Israel,” says Keck “have virtually sealed the joint development of a medium-range surface-to-air-missile system (MRSAM) for the Indian army. The first tranche of the deal is worth $1.67 billion.”

    Keck also quoted some ‘unidentified’ Indian army official saying that “Delhi could purchase over $6 billion worth of the medium-range surface-to-air missiles and related systems from Israel by the end of the deal.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s